Volume 8, Issue 11 - December 2007
Housing Market Remains Bleak
by Tara Taffera
“I don’t think anyone is looking for housing to turn around in 2008,” said Robert Murray, vice president of economic affairs for McGraw-Hill Construction. This was the message he and other experts gave to those who attended the Construction Outlook 2008 Executive Conference held in October in Washington, D.C. Murray presented the 2008 outlook for U.S. construction activity.
The bleak forecast is due in part to tighter lending conditions and high inventories, according to Murray. Many speakers addressed the inventory problem, including Kermit Baker, chief economist for the American Institute of Architects (AIA), who presented an outlook for the housing and remodeling markets. He cited the statistic that inventories of vacant for sale homes ballooned—with an increase over 2005-2006 estimated at 750,000-800,000.“This is the problem we have to work off until things get back to normal,” said Baker.
He said we could see a recovery in 2009 but was tentative with that prediction.
Though homebuilding is in the midst of a significant downturn, Baker said, “With every day this is becoming more significant than first expected.”
Though the next few years may look dismal, he did say that the long-term housing outlook is positive as there is strong household growth (which should be even greater in the coming decade than in the last), a vibrant second-home market and a more efficient industry as a whole. Negatives include affordability, land-use restrictions and high energy costs.
While new construction falters, Baker said remodeling does offer opportunities. He said positives for the long-term remodeling outlook are the aging housing stock, rising land prices/energy costs and high homeowner equity levels. “Often this translates into home improvement spending,” he said. Although the remodeling market has almost doubled since 1995, there is concern for this segment as well, including:
But again, the long-term outlook is positive.
“Once the housing market stabilizes remodeling will go up,” he said.
Baker also enumerated some remodeling trends, based on findings from an AIA design trends survey. He said energy-efficient and low-maintenance products are valued when homeowners select products and added that this includes “triple-glazed windows.”
And he ended his forecast with more good news: “It’s an industry that has a strong upside in the coming decade.”
Many in the door and window industries rely on predictions such as Murray’s to help them plan for the coming year. For example, representatives from companies such as PPG, VT Industries and Harring Doors attended the conference this year.
“It’s important for us to hear about the economy from a national perspective that focuses specifically on the construction industry,” said Tim Petersen, national sales manager, architectural wood doors, for VT Industries. “It is useful for establishing baseline sales targets for the upcoming sales year.”
Building Materials to Remain Relatively Flat
Economic Outlook: Fair
“Housing is the only major weakness; the rest of the economy is still growing [at a rate of] nearly3 percent,” he said.
Wyss noted that the weaknesses aren’t found in the high-priced markets. Rather, the default rates are highest in the Midwest and the South. He said that employment is finally improving, which is helping construction. He did, however, question whether the consumer can keep spending.
“A risk of recession remains if further terror attacks damage confidence, while oil prices soar. Financing problems push the dollar down and U.S. bond yields higher,” he told attendees.
This falling of the dollar value has some companies like Canadian door manufacturer Harring Doors concerned.
“As a Canadian manufacturer who sells into the United States, the presentations given confirmed that the dollar will decline, which won’t help us,” said Sandy McTavish, vice president.
Experts Forecast Green Days Ahead
Shortly after the panel discussion an entire session was devoted to this topic. Rick Fedrizzi, president of the U.S. Green Building Council, gave a green construction outlook for 2008. He said the key to getting buy-in for green buildings is to have a strong business case. For example, focus on items such as tenant retention for green buildings and provide proven facts:
While many may think building green has high costs, he quickly debunked this myth.
“The number-one mistruth is that it costs more to build green. There is study upon study that proves that for the first two levels of LEED a building can be constructed for not a penny more,” he said. “A $4 investment in building green nets a $58 benefit per square foot over 20 years.”
He also pointed out that LEED buildings can reduce carbon omissions by 40 percent. “This is what it’s all about,” he said. “We are in the midst of the biggest societal shift since World War II … We’re humans. We want to address these problems. We don’t want to leave a legacy of filth,” he added.
Growth in green construction is anticipated. The tipping point, Murray said, is expected to come in a market shift over the next three years. By 2009, 80 percent of corporate America is expected to be engaged in green activities at least 15 percent of the time, and 20 percent will be engaged in green activities 60 percent of the time. Representatives from the door industry already are involved in providing green products. “Environmental issues help to reinforce the ongoing steps our organization is involved with concerning the national focus on sustainable design and projects,” said Tim Petersen, national sales manager, architectural wood doors, for VT Industries.
Sandy McTavish, vice president of manufacturing for Harring Doors, agreed, saying he took a lot from the green presentation. “Green requirements are showing up in a lot of specifications right now,” he said. “Whether we get the job or not it gets our name out there [that we provide green products]."
Another View:Housing Market to Bottom Out, Turn Next Year
Experts acknowledge that there is definitely downward momentum in the market at this time. Starts, sales, prices and permits are off, and problems in the subprime and Alt-A mortgage markets, NAHB chief economist David Seiders said that housing should nevertheless begin a modest recovery next year.
Despite the present market contraction, Seiders said that housing should begin to look up next year for a number of reasons: the overall economy and job growth continue to move ahead at a decent pace, core inflation is under control, the late-summer credit crunch in mortgage markets is showing signs of easing since the Federal Reserve cut short-term interest rates on September 18 and the supply-demand equation will be better balanced as builders begin to whittle down excess inventories.
It is this issue of excess inventories upon which experts at both conferences agree. With the housing sector facing a large backlog of unsold inventory, Seiders said that starts and permits won’t begin to move forward until sales firm up.
“Home sales should bottom out by the end of the first quarter of 2008, and I have starts up in the third quarter of next year, assuming the inventory overhang stabilizes,” he said.Following are some other predictions offered by Seiders:
Maury Harris, managing director and chief economist at UBS Investment Bank, agrees, saying he sees “housing bottoming out in the first half of 2008 and starting to pick up in the second half of the year.”
The last time a housing recession was this serious was in the mid-1960s, Harris said, but the big difference between then and now is that “the Fed is not dealing with inflation.”
If something does halt a recovery Harris said it will be the 500,000 foreclosures on subprime and Alt-A loans both this year and next.
“The foreclosures aggravate the inventory situation and weigh on the market more than in past cycles,” he said.
However, Michael Moran, chief economist for Daiwa Securities America Inc., said that the mortgage picture is not as bad as it looks. “Twenty percent of the subprime market is under stress,” said Moran. “Twenty percent of 13 percent is less than 3 percent of the total mortgage market. The economy should absorb this shock.”
As for the high number of foreclosures expected this year and next, Moran said the economic fallout will not be as severe as many analysts anticipate because the vast majority of the affected homeowners made little or no down payment on their houses and will walk away without much of a loss.
While there may be disagreement on a few issues experts seem to agree that the housing picture looks much better in 2009. “By the end of 2009, we may be at a pace of 1.5 million units of new housing production (including manufactured homes). Once we are out of the woods, we should see good growth in front of us—maybe 2 million per year,” said Seiders.
Tara Taffera is the publisher/editor of DWM magazine.